
Mike Mussina has decided to call it quits which can only mean that it is time for everyone’s favorite act of futility: An argument over whether or not his career merits a plaque in Cooperstown.
FOR:
Consistency: From his first full year with the Orioles in ’92 through last season, Moose had one losing season. He won over 15 games and pitched over 200 innings 11 out of his 17 seasons full seasons. He was top six in Cy Young voting nine times spanning the length of his career -- third in voting during his first full season and sixth in voting in his final season.
Wins. Moose has 270 career victories. There are only six players with that many wins, or more, who aren’t in the Hall of Fame. Four of those six aren’t eligible yet, and are locks for Cooperstown. So really, the only two 270-win pitchers not in the Hall are Bert Blyleven (who many believe will get in someday) and Bobby Mathews, who played baseball in the 1800s. He also racked up 100 more wins than losses for an outstanding win percentage of .638. (Correction: Jim Kaat and Tommy John both have more than 270 and aren't in the Hall. So make that four pitchers with 270 who aren't currently in the Hall, or locks to gain entrance in the coming years.)
Strikouts. He came up short of the 3,000 K plateau, but he did strikeout 2,816, good enough for 19th all-time. Nearly every pitcher above him on the all-time K list is, or will be, a Hall of Famer.
Gold Gloves. The credibility and importance of the award is suspect, but he won seven of them, for whatever that’s worth. It’s certainly not a negative and he was, without question, a great defensive pitcher.
Read the rest of this entry »